Editing & Grading 4K: Windows or Mac

IMG_9052

I’ve been an Apple fan since I bought my first iMac back in 2005. I didn’t have the money for it but at that point I didn’t care because I’d had enough of Windows. About 5 weeks previous our latest short film was due to be shown privately in a local cinema and of course, my PC decided to stop working and wipe the hard drive in the process. Although I still hold a grudge, I’ll try and not let this influence my review too much.

Since 2005 I’ve purchased a further 5 Apple computers; a 24” Dual Core iMac, 2 x 27” i7’s iMacs, a 21” i3 iMac and a 15” i7 MacBook Pro. 4 of which are still purring away (quietly) as if they were brand new. 

In October 2016, we were commissioned to make two explainer videos for a travel company. All was going well; script, storyboard & illustrations. This was, until we started animating. To put this into perspective, it normally takes between 30 minutes and 2 hours to render 2D animation via Adobe After Effects. But this new video was taking over 30 hours to render because of all the brush strokes. The video had to be rendered in vector due to the nature of the animation so we had no choice. I immediately knew that our existing computers didn’t have the power to handle this type of file.

Being an Apple fan. I went straight onto the Apple website to take a look at the Mac Pros. Without getting into too much detail. £10K? Really? For something that hasn’t been updated since 2013. I like Apple a lot, but not that much. If you saw all what I owned created by Apple you would label me as a brand loyal person. I am not, I am loyal to what works for me. Anyway, who in their right mind would buy 3 year old technology that is limited to 64GB ram?

Apple -1 vs -1 PC

So, I went back to the dark side. I found PC Specialist online and thought “Why not?”. Surely Windows can’t be that bad anymore? So £6K later I ended up with what I have today. If you’re interested in the spec…

10 Core Intel Xeon Asus 3.1Ghz

128 GB Ram 2133Mhz

12GB Nvidia Titax X Pascal

1TB Samsung SSD

6TB Sata HDD.

pc

My new PC arrived in the world’s biggest box. I couldn’t help but think that PC Specialist must be a very cautious company. However, this wasn’t the case, or in this case, it was the case. A HUGE case. I mean I knew it was a tower but this is mental. Why does it need to be this big?

apple-vs-mac

It’s only when you see how small my iMac is compared to this behemoth that you truly appreciate the engineering from the people at Apple. Point to Apple.

Apple 0  vs -1 PC

It isn’t just big either, this Corsair tower is disgusting. I don’t need to argue this point. Just look at the photo above. Yes I picked it, but there is no good choice. If you find one, let me know in the comments. 

But why does this matter? Well, the look of a computer plays a role when it comes to what you produce. Why do you think artists hide themselves away in their own paradise to produce their best work and don’t just jump on the first train to Kilmarnock. Your surroundings matter. 

Apple 1 vs – 1 PC

Let’s turn it on. Oh, one second, I’ve left the oven on… oven isn’t on. Ah, it’s the computer. Why is it so loud? It needs to stay cool, I agree. My iMac has this issue as well. But only when it’s actually working hard. It’s like listening to an overweight person breathing. It’s not really work but by God it sounds like it is. Let me present you with an actual recording of both starting up. Make sure to listen to all of the PC one as there is a little surprise for the Windows lover. For the geek out there, they are both running off an SSD.

 

Apple 2 vs -1 PC

Oooh. The 4K monitor is lovely. Hideous base but I’m going to wall mount it anyway. The fact that you can’t wall mount an iMac is frustrating. It’s not like they’re that heavy. This is something I would love to do with my iMacs. 

Apple 2 vs 0 PC

My biggest gripe with the PC isn’t the OS, or the giant box that it comes with it, but it’s the crap mice and keyboards on offer. No matter where I look, I see nothing that comes close to the look and feel of the Apple keyboard. I only need one good keyboard and one good mouse. They’ve not evolved in 24 years. They’re just as clumsy as they were with my family’s first Packard Bell back in 1993.

On the plus side, I’ve bought a USB bluetooth unit and have managed to pair my Apple keyboard and mouse with the PC. I’m still working on making this hassle free. At present, I have to plug in and disconnect any random USB device to prompt it every so often when it freezes. You gotta love Windows.

Apple 3 vs 0 PC

The PC, when it works, is amazing. It isn’t quiet, it isn’t pretty and it isn’t small but I still like it. I can edit and grade in 4K. Yeah, my iMac can do that as well to a degree. But it stalls, it grumbles, it can crash on occasion. I hate turning the quality down to ¼ or having to convert my footage into another format. I hate working around a problem when there shouldn’t be a problem. This is why the PC was worth every single penny. If you’re an animator and reading this, have you ever wanted to watch your animation live whilst you’re animating it at full FPS? Then get a PC with the spec above. 

I rendered that explainer video that took over 30 hours in less than 12 hours. Plus, I could still do whatever else I wanted on the computer because it was only using 42% of the power (you need to get this sorted Adobe!) I seriously doubt that I’ll need to buy anything else until I upgrade my camera kit to 8K in the next 3-4 years. 

PC; you deserve 2 points.

Apple 3 vs 2 PC

Even though I have my PC sitting next to me ready and waiting with a nice keyboard and mouse, I’ve still opted to write this post on my iMac. It’s just a superior experience. I get both sides of the argument, I really do. Apple is crazy expensive and does the job; but you don’t have to configure it or work out why the mouse and keyboard keep freezing. PC is cheaper and does the job; but you have to fiddle with it a lot to make it do the things you want but it can be much faster if you spec it right. As a power user I’d have to advise fellow 4K editor/animators to run with PC. It hurts to say that. As a business, we’ve invested a lot of money in Apple products over the years and I’m feeling let down due to the lack of support for the power user. C’mon Apple, get the finger out. Win us back. Create something that we don’t mind overspending on.  

I guess, for now, I’ll have to settle for Stockholm syndrome.

 

Comments 4

  1. Wow, beast of a machine! I’ve been pretty happy with my SilverStone FT02 case, motherboard is rotated so all I/O is on the top for easy access, pretty sleek design BUT it weighs a ton! I’ve not used a Mac since college back in 2003. guess I don’t know what I’m missing out on 😉

    1. Post
      Author
  2. As a Windows user reading though this, it seems a little unfair to mark down the PC for looks, size and sound, as these are direct results of your specification choices. You could have easily chosen a better looking, smaller “mid tower” with sound proofing and silent fans which would have made a huge difference.

    Your notes on keyboard and mouse options are quite amusing too. Sure, the exact mouse and keyboard you prefer don’t work perfectly with a PC, but they DO work with a system that was never designed for them. For someone with no existing preference, the colossal range of options for a PC setup should surely be a point to the PC?

    Finally, I would have given a handful of points to the PC purely for the price difference. Only 60% of the price of the Mac, twice as powerful AND comes with a 4K monitor? It’s quite surreal when I think about it.

    1. Post
      Author

      Thank you for commenting, Alex. Do you have any suggestions for towers that are pretty? I looked at a lot and just couldn’t find anything well designed.

      My gripe is that I’m given a choice. Why should you have to choose a silent fan? It should just be silent. I could buy any Apple computer and it would be pretty and silent. This kind of stuff is all taken care of.

      And regarding the price difference. The computer I have just now is half the speed and was less than half the price. I think it was £2400 which has a 2K monitor built in. Plus it’s compact, pretty and silent. The Mac Pro I’m sure would be faster but I can’t say how long that render would have taken. I just didn’t want to spend £10K on something that was old tech. I’d happily spend £10K on something up to date. I’m lucky to have spent time on both Apple and Windows and so far, I still prefer Apple. I will write another post after a year. You never know, I may have another PC! But I think I’ll still prefer the Mac.
      Once again, thank you for the comment 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *